11 Comments
User's avatar
mark e's avatar

Well-written! And profoundly disheartening. I agree with you. And I strongly wish things were not this way (and becoming more so by the year)...

Anya Kaats's avatar

Me too. What we have or are capable of is certainly better than nothing/not trying, but yes, reality is far less shiny than our ideals. Thanks for reading!

Iuval Clejan's avatar

Recognizing mistakes is not disheartening, is it? Ignoring them and pretending everything is fine is disheartening? We can learn from mistakes and try to improve.

Marie's avatar

It was a nice insight to read your thoughts on this matter. I live in a collective space with 10 other people and 5 kids and we work in a completely horizontal way. As well as being our home, our living space is home to cultural activities, artist residences, events, etc.

After 8 years experience, I have to say I pretty much agree with your affirmations.

The conflict is constant and almost unresolvable. Individuality impossible to let go of. Wise and knowledgeable figures or frames of reference inexistent. And there are as many points of views as there are people.

I have come to question the modern human capacity to work horizontally, to my great disappointment/disillusionment.

We are still here. Barely holding on. In a constant crisis. But here. Trying constantly to do things outside a system that has become bone deep in each one of us.

But apart from the constant difficulties There is a beautiful sensation and a profound belief in the value of what we are building, and also the glue that shared experience, especially difficult ones, that holds us together. Even if it is infinitely hard and constantly testing, it still compensates. I still stay. Although I sometimes wonder how much this situation has in common with what would be a toxic romantic relationship.

The hard is very hard. But the good is so good….

Anya Kaats's avatar

Thank you so much for sharing your experience. I think people are hesitant to talk about what isn't working in these contexts, because we still believe in them so much and still want to believe they can work. I can tell that people are averse to me naming the struggle because they're fighting so hard for this thing to work and to be accepted by a culture that is working so hard to discredit it. I get it, I just can't continue to operate with rose colored glasses. I think honesty is always the best strategy, even when we are fighting for cultural acceptance.

Anyway, I really appreciate you validating these thoughts. I agree - the good is so good, and I still feel committed, and I hope we all have the strength to face what's getting in the way to help this was of life be sustained more long term.

Someone said something to me recently that I thought was really wise and inspiring. In the past, we were forced to live communally, bound together by survival. Then we went through a period where we all needed to individuate and create our life on our own terms. Now, we are being given the opportunity to form relationships and communal bonds based on a higher level of consciousness and based on choice, rather than being forced by survival.

I've been thinking about that a lot. It makes sense to me. Just the fact that we are trying is inspiring. Just the effort is enough for now and we certainly can't get anywhere without trying!

Marie's avatar

Yes, not acknowledging the difficulty of such realities is doing it a disservice I think. Two opposites can co-exist. Living in community is one of the most wonderful AND hardest things I have ever done. It is constantly testing. But also constantly making me grow. Full of beautiful memories and experiences, and very tough ones. And who knows where this will end, but the way there will always be worth it won’t it? since it helped forge who I am.

Nothing can be disregarded until we have tried! We are in an era where all schemes need to be reinvented and so far trial and error seems to be the only way to go about it. So let’s keep trying!

Thank you for sharing your thoughts and nurturing my own reflexions.

Dave?'s avatar

I experienced a small taste of communal living a few years ago when I took a course in building with cob at Cobb Cottage Company out in Bandon, OR. Although I wasn’t there long enough to get a true read on any of personal dynamics that might be going on among the teachers and residents, I did come away with a feeling of harmony and shared work ethic. There also was a sense of peacefulness that I experienced again this last summer when my wife and I visited Bandelier National Monument in New Mexico. The Pueblo site was abandoned in 1600, but as we toured the site on foot an overwhelming feeling of calmness and tranquility washed over us. It’s crazy to think that positive energy could still be hanging in the air or maybe resonating from the rocks but it was the kind of good vibe feelings we usually only got after a full day of sitting on the beach and staring at the ocean. I came away with the thought that maybe that comforting sense of community lies buried somewhere deep within us all despite the harmful distractions of modern society.

Anya Kaats's avatar

I love this sentiment, and agree! Certainly living in this way alongside one another exists somewhere in our DNA, and I am grateful that so many of us are waking up to that knowing and awareness. I certainly think that harmony and shared work ethic is prevalent in communities, but when it comes to really needing to ensure things function sustainably over the long term, there are a lot of challenges.

Justin Caraway's avatar

Thank you for sharing! I too have been attempting retribalization as I like to call it. Met some awesome village grandmas I love, stay in contact with and visit when I can. Sadly I couldn't create the structure for us to inhibit. I think looking towards the Amish, how a strong belief system can overcome the culture around it is an inspiration for what we could do, if a different sort of belief system was to arise. Or as things continue to collapse, the hardship should make the benefits of community greater and greater. Maybe a small group, as small as possible, all in alignment and slowly growing over time is what it'll take. I'm not sure.

I had a dinner with random city people on the Timeleft app, a young woman told me she wishes she could care about living in community and growing food, but she doesn't. The abundance of our society allows us all to be disconnected. A lot of people don't care about community or are too corrupted by surviving in modern life. Another big herdle I see if that most of the US community is illegal, or has been made so expensive to be only for the upper crust. Cohousing for example is usually only in big cities, very expensive, and created mostly by retired rich white people.

Colin Brandon's avatar

I like your take, it's a lucid and nonjudgmental assessment of what defines more authentic communal living. I once visited an intentional community for a few months and got a good taste of what it's like to consistently reciprocate with many others on a daily basis to meet essential life needs of everyone. It came with its challenges, but they were some of the most content, compassionate, and good-faith people I've been around.

I've also traveled for many years by myself doing work exchange and house/pet/farm sitting, which are more community-oriented forms of travel. When I began traveling in that way, I experienced a really uncomfortable adjustment period, but after repeatedly putting myself in situations where I had to rely on others (and they had to rely on me), I experienced the natural unfolding of human trust and generosity, time and again.

Iuval Clejan's avatar

Thanks for naming these 4, and you nailed it. I wish more folks in the IC world would read this and comment. There might be design solutions for these, if they are intentional communities.

1. Require everyone who lives in the village to be a contributor in some way that other people need their goods or services, produced by them individually, as a family or as a producer coop.

2 As you say: clear boundaries about what each member is responsible as a contributor to the community.

3. Individual freedom can be optimized at the same time as collective responsibilities and communion, but there are tradeoffs. Some of it can be improved by a network structure that is nested: individuals within families and coops, coops and families within villages, villages within a network of villages, with subsidiarity. Having 200 or more people in a village without the intermediate level of families is asking for avoidable conflict. Same with millions of people in a nation without the intermediates of networks, villages and families.

It also helps to have a common story, ideology or religion, in order to align people to a common goal.

4. This is one reason conservative religious communities do better (less turnover, longer lasting) than liberal ones. So maybe we need to have some more conservative community members to help us respect earned authority and wisdom.